Family-owned Ohio agency · Since 1989
Home, auto, life and business coverage from an independent Westerville agency that shops multiple carriers to fit your life — and actually answers the phone.
What we cover
One independent agency for your whole world — we compare carriers so you don't have to, then help you pick what actually fits.
Protect your house and everything in it — homeowners coverage matched to what you actually own.
The right coverage at the right price — we shop multiple carriers so you're never overpaying.
Peace of mind for the people who count on you, with guidance that's honest and jargon-free.
From storefronts to trades — coverage that keeps your Ohio business protected and running.
Why Fetchero
We've been the Fetchero family looking after Ohio families since 1989. Independent means we work for you — not one insurance company.
We compare multiple carriers to find the best fit and price, then explain the trade-offs plainly.
Two generations of know-how — you get answers fast, from people who've seen it all.
Right here in Westerville — a name you can put a face to, and a team that treats you like a neighbor.
Our promise
Coverage is only half of it. The other half is knowing someone local has your back when life happens — and that's what the Fetchero family has done for over three decades.
Get a free quoteMeet the family
Real, local people with more than 60 years of combined experience — here to make insurance simple.
Leads the agency with the same personal, no-pressure service the family's been known for since 1989.
Founded Fetchero Insurance in 1989 and built its reputation on honesty and doing right by clients.
The friendly voice on the phone — quick answers, fast follow-up, and help whenever you need it.
What clients say
"Superior customer service and they are very knowledgeable at what they do."
"Quick responses and great customer service."
"They answer any and all questions… response time is almost immediate."
Get started